About 45% of homeowners surveyed by ACHR News expect a replacement HVAC system to cost less than $7,500. Contractors in the same research put a typical job at $10,000 to $15,000. For an owner staring at a quote that’s at least $2,500 above what the customer imagined, the question is whether to cut the number or change how it’s presented. The three contractors ACHR News put on a panel about the findings described presentation tactics, and none described cutting price.
The numbers have limits. “Nearly half” is a minority, and ACHR News did not report how the other 55% answered. The figure measures what homeowners expect, not what they paid, so it is not evidence that contractors are overpriced. The research was run by myCLEARopinion Insights Hub for ACHR News’s parent company, BNP Media. ACHR News has reported it covers 782 U.S. homeowners and 205 contractors, surveyed April 24 to May 19, 2026. ACHR News described the $7,500 expectation in a companion article as applying to a full HVAC replacement. It applies to HVAC homeowners and ACHR-reached contractors, not to plumbing, electrical or other trades.
Why discounting doesn’t close a $2,500-plus gap
ACHR News reports that 53% of contractors put a typical full replacement at $10,000 or more, with the largest group, 40%, in the $10,000 to $14,999 band. It also reports that 73% of contractors say they earn margins of 11% to 25% on full replacements, with 16% to 20% the most common band at 36%.
Consider a hypothetical $12,500 job in that most common band. The margin is roughly $2,000 to $2,500. Meeting a homeowner at $7,500 would mean giving up about $5,000, which is more than the entire margin. Even splitting the difference wipes it out. Those margin figures are self-reported and ACHR News’s summary does not define them, so the arithmetic is illustrative. But the math is consistent with the panelists’ approach of focusing on what the homeowner expects rather than on cutting price.
Like this? Get it in your inbox every week.
What changed in home services this week, and what it means for your shop.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
You’re in. Check your inbox (and drag us to Primary). 🔑
Three owners, three sequences
According to ACHR News’s account of the roundtable at the HVAC Contractor Forum in Frisco, Texas, the panelists agreed on the goal and split on tactics. All of what follows is the contractors’ own description of their companies, not measured results.
- Before the visit. Scott Merritt of Honest Fix Heating, Cooling and Plumbing in Steubenville, Ohio, publishes price ranges for nearly every equipment type. He says the pricing page is his site’s most-viewed page. His company also sends a pricing sheet and a short video ahead of the sales call, and he says that can weed out leads that aren’t a fit. “It’s people’s first question,” Merritt said, adding that a range can carry the caveat that final cost depends on a site visit.
- During the visit. Brynn Cooksey Sr. of Air Doctors Heating and Cooling in Southfield, Michigan, wants to be the last quote in the house. His process includes load calculations and duct assessments he says competitors may skip. He also argues owners have to explain why the old system failed, not just why the new one costs what it does, and uses readings customers can follow, such as delivered Btu.
- In the quote order. Merritt and Martin Hoover of Empire Heating & Air Conditioning in Decatur, Georgia, prefer going first. Merritt hands homeowners a checklist of about 10 things to compare bids on, including warranties. Hoover cites a first-call close rate in the 30%-plus range, but credits a large planned-maintenance base of repeat customers. Hoover is also the most cautious about posting prices, because ductwork and site conditions can change the final cost. He also said equipment prices have more than doubled in six years.
The survey did not test whether any of these tactics raise close rates, and ACHR News’s conclusion that explaining things may keep price from being the deciding factor is the reporter’s judgment.
Where the gap opens first
The clearest data point is on price transparency. ACHR News reports that about three in four homeowners say they’re more likely to call a contractor that lists pricing, while only 24% of contractors post prices on their sites. That is stated preference, not observed behavior. It does not show when homeowners first hear a number or how they react to it, so your own call and quote records are the place to check where that happens in your shop.
The assessment fee is another place where homeowners and contractors diverge. ACHR News reports that 43% of contractors charge one, averaging $119, against $75 for homeowners who say they’d pay one. In a 2024 ACHR study, only 14% of homeowners said they’d likely get a quote from a contractor charging a visit fee. A fee may screen out some price-shoppers, but that 2024 figure suggests it could screen out buyers too.
Stated intent on quotes needs the same caution. ACHR News reports 54% of homeowners say they’d gather three quotes and 32% two, though earlier ACHR coverage warns this is intent, not behavior. One contractor quoted there says “three quotes” often means the homeowner doesn’t want to be sold that day.
What an owner can do with it
The useful audit is of the call-to-quote path. Where does a homeowner first hear a price range: on the website, on the phone, or at the end of the visit? If the answer is the end of the visit, the gap is landing at the worst moment. Posting a range with a site-visit caveat, as Merritt does, is a low-cost test, as is a short pre-visit video. Track how many leads drop after hearing the range versus after the quote. That tells an owner whether the losses are price-shoppers who were never buyers, or buyers who needed the expectation set earlier.
Manufacturer pricing may matter here too. Lennox said in its third-quarter release on October 28 that Home Comfort Solutions revenue rose 3% while segment margin fell 490 basis points, citing “targeted price adjustments” in select segments and new entry-tier products among its priorities. If lower-priced equipment does reach the channel, it could give shops a lower-cost option to offer. That is a possibility, not a result, and nothing in the ACHR research says a cheaper tier would close the gap with homeowners expecting under $7,500.
Related coverage
Sources
- ACHR News: What Homeowners Expect When They Call an HVAC Contractor (Nov. 17, 2026)
- ACHR News: Mind the Gap: Data Shows What Homeowners Are Missing When it Comes to HVAC Pricing
- myCLEARopinion Insights Hub: The NEWS 2026 Homeowner Study (report page)
- Lennox Q3 2026 earnings release (SEC Form 8-K, Ex. 99.1)
- ACHR News: To Fee or Not to Fee (2024 visit-fee study)
- ACHR News: 36% of Homeowners Draw the Line at AI Replacing HVAC Expertise (sample size and fieldwork dates)
More on this topic: Business & Finance coverage



