Trade headlines say existing home sales hit a 16-year low, and the work that follows comes from the homeowner who has to make this house last another decade.
A few weeks ago, a homeowner called my plumbing company about an aging water heater. It started as a straightforward service call.
Then the homeowner told our technician they’d been thinking about moving for the last two years, but there was no way they were giving up their mortgage rate. Their words, roughly: “I guess we’re going to be here another ten years.”
That changed the conversation. Our tech started asking about the other plumbing they’d been putting off. A couple of fixtures were giving them problems, and there was other work they’d been meaning to get to.
Like this? Get it in your inbox every week.
What changed in home services this week, and what it means for your shop.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
You’re in. Check your inbox (and drag us to Primary). 🔑
The homeowner wasn’t opposed to spending money. They were opposed to spending money on a house they thought they were leaving. Once they accepted they were staying, those repairs became investments in the next ten years of their lives. That’s a different buying mindset, and I think a lot of contractors are missing it.
Trade headlines this month describe a housing market that’s frozen. That homeowner is what a frozen market looks like from the truck.
Where I’m coming from
I own home service companies and I sell lead generation to contractors, so I make money when your phone rings. Weigh everything below with that in mind. Of the six trades we’ve operated in, moving is the one most directly tied to home sales. Plumbing, electrical and roofing get called whether the customer is buying, selling or staying put.
My read: the stay-put economy
Picture a fleet owner who can’t swap out his trucks at today’s prices. He doesn’t stop spending on the fleet. He rebuilds the engine and keeps the old truck on the road another 100,000 miles. A homeowner on a 3% mortgage is that owner. They’re not trading in the house. They’re rebuilding it, and the shop that sells the rebuild gets the money.
I’m calling this the stay-put economy. Homeowners locked into a low rate may not stop spending on the house. They may just spend differently. Here’s how I’d sort it.
Four kinds of work that grow
- Deferred maintenance. I think this is the biggest opportunity of the four. Plenty of homeowners spent three years telling themselves they’d move. They skipped the water heater, ignored the electrical panel and put Band-Aids on plumbing because the next owner could deal with it. Now they’re realizing they may be there another decade.
- Repair-or-replace decisions on aging systems. Sometimes the repair is right. Sometimes replacement makes more financial sense.
- Bundled projects. Several problems solved together instead of one at a time.
- Make-it-work remodels. The kitchen, the basement, the plumbing, the electrical, whatever gets the house working for another ten years.
Three kinds that likely dry up
- Pre-sale repair lists.
- Repairs driven by a buyer’s inspection.
- Move-in and move-out work, including moving itself.
The second list is a likely outcome, not something I’ve measured. I don’t have pre-sale or move-in work broken out in my numbers, so I can’t tell you it’s already slowing in my shops.
A Roofing Contractor piece (Nov. 8) from the Win the Storm event in Dallas reports roofing-related insurance claims down 11.9% through August versus the same period in 2025, citing Verisk. Joaquín Garza of X Roofing and Solar in Dallas-Fort Worth said the work is out there for contractors who go after it, including homeowners nobody followed up with after earlier storms.
The sales conversation is where this gets won or lost. Don’t take it as permission to upsell everybody who walks in. If a homeowner needs a $400 repair and that’s the right fix, sell the $400 repair. But if they’ve got a 17-year-old water heater, outdated plumbing and three other issues they’ve been avoiding, you owe them a conversation about the bigger picture.
The question I’d train every tech and CSR to ask: “If you knew you were going to live in this house for another ten years, would you still want to handle this problem the same way?” It isn’t a pitch or a financing trick. Spending $2,000 to keep an old system limping along makes sense if you’re selling in six months. If you’re staying a decade, replacing it may be worth considering. The customer still decides. You don’t sell them more stuff. You help them make better decisions about the house they’re actually going to live in.
Financing belongs in that conversation, with care. Stop assuming that because someone owns a $700,000 house, they have $15,000 sitting in checking for a surprise repair. They may have plenty of equity and great income and still not want to drain their savings. Financing lets them spread it out. I don’t believe in using it to push someone into something they don’t need. And know your merchant fees, your terms and your real margin. If financing costs eat your profit, you’re just buying revenue.
The wrong damn conversation about housing
I think we’re having the wrong conversation. Everybody wants to talk about mortgage rates: lower them, stimulate the market, get people buying again. But what good is a lower rate if there still aren’t enough affordable houses to buy? Millions of homeowners feel financially trapped. They may have a growing family, need another bedroom or want to be closer to work. But walking away from a 3% mortgage to take a 6% or 7% one can mean hundreds or thousands more every month. So they stay.
The strongest opposing argument is that rates are what’s freezing the market, and relief would free up listings and get people moving again, which helps everyone from agents to movers. I don’t think that’s wrong as far as it goes. And government can’t wave a magic wand and set mortgage rates wherever it wants. That’s not how mortgage markets work. But helping another million people qualify for financing doesn’t create another million houses. You can’t solve a shortage by pretending everybody just needs a cheaper loan.
What drives me nuts is how we treat affordability like it’s only an interest-rate problem. I’ve watched projects get more expensive before a contractor puts a shovel in the ground: permitting costs, zoning restrictions, inspection requirements, utility connections and approval processes that drag on while the owner pays interest on the money they borrowed. Every dollar added to the cost of building gets paid by somebody, usually the homeowner.
I’m not arguing we should scrap building codes or let contractors do whatever they want. I’ve been around the trades long enough to know why safety standards exist. But there’s a real difference between regulations that protect people and processes that just add expense and delay. I’d apply that scrutiny to local, state and federal housing policy alike.
A homeowner spending $30,000 remodeling because they can’t afford to move is not necessarily evidence of a healthy housing economy.
It might be a family making the best of a difficult situation. Our industry shouldn’t celebrate revenue growth without asking what’s creating it. More remodeling doesn’t mean consumers are healthier, and more revenue doesn’t mean more profit.
The other side
The best counterargument isn’t political. It’s math, and I concede it completely. If new construction falls, and the Builder headline says starts pulled back, remodeling’s share of building can rise without remodeling growing at all. Say new construction drops 20% and remodeling stays flat. Remodeling is suddenly a bigger percentage of total activity. That doesn’t mean remodelers are making more money. The denominator changed.
I’ve seen the same thinking in marketing. Somebody tells me their leads are up 40% and I’m supposed to be impressed. My next question: how much additional revenue did you collect, and how much of it turned into profit? Leads don’t pay your bills. Market share doesn’t equal market growth. I don’t care if remodeling becomes 60% of building. If total spending is down and contractors are fighting over fewer projects, that’s not a booming market. Show me total dollars, project volume, average tickets and contractor margins. Then we can talk.
Nobody knows how long rates stay high, or whether remodeling’s share holds. Anything past the headlines is speculation.
Who gains, who loses
Moving companies are the obvious losers, since their business is directly tied to people changing homes. The less obvious loser is the contractor who built his whole business around the housing transaction: the roofer living on inspection objections, the electrician fixing items before a closing, the plumber called because the buyer’s inspector found a problem. Those jobs exist because a house is changing hands, and when transactions slow, that demand gets less dependable.
I think a worse-off group is contractors with high overhead who assumed the phone would always ring. Expensive trucks, big office teams, heavy software bills and ad budgets that only work at full capacity don’t shrink when job volume does. A company doing $300,000 a month can be financially weaker than one doing $180,000. The difference is what it costs to produce that revenue.
On the gain side, my read is service and repair shops with a good options conversation, and remodelers who can price and finance well. That’s a likely read, not a measured one. I don’t think this market rewards the biggest contractor. I think it rewards the one who knows his numbers and adapts faster than his competitors.
Do this week
- Pull the last 12 months of tickets and tag each one: pre-sale or inspection, move-in, or stay-put. You can’t chase a shift you haven’t measured.
- Teach your techs and CSRs the ten-year question, and have them present options on any aging system: repair, replace or bundle. Then let the customer choose.
- Get your financing numbers on one page: merchant fee, term and your net margin on a $15,000 financed job versus a cash one.
- Call past customers with aging systems and follow up on every quote that went quiet. The Dallas roofers in that Roofing Contractor piece said the work goes to whoever keeps reaching out.
- Drop any financing offer you wouldn’t be comfortable explaining to the customer’s face.
What would change my mind
- Rates come down, existing-home transactions recover, and the customers I’m calling stay-put homeowners start selling instead of upgrading. Then the market has changed.
- Revenue per opportunity stays flat. If homeowners stay longer but don’t spend more on maintenance, replacements and improvements, the stay-put economy is a good story and not a good business. I’d watch repair-versus-replacement ratios, average tickets, financing adoption, estimate close rates, revenue from existing customers and gross margin on the bigger jobs.
- Total remodeling dollars, not share, come in flat or down in the NAHB and Census data.
I don’t build my businesses around what economists predict for next year. I build them around what customers are doing right now, so sort your tickets this week and see what yours are doing.
Sources
- Finance & Commerce: U.S. existing home sales hit 16-year low as rates climb
- Builder Magazine: Housing Starts Pull Back, but Top Markets Hold Their Ground
- National Mortgage News: NAHB: Remodeling to top 50% of building; ready rehab loans
- Roofing Contractor: Contratistas de roofing adaptan sus servicios en zonas con pocas tormentas
More on this topic: Business & Finance coverage




