If you do insurance roofing work in Oklahoma, some of your past customers may be about to get a letter saying their denied or underpaid wind or hail claim can be reviewed again. State Farm must mail notices to eligible homeowners by Dec. 31. The money behind it is real. It goes to homeowners, though, not to contractors, and nothing reported so far gives roofers a formal role.
On Nov. 13, the Oklahoma Insurance Department announced a settlement with State Farm Fire and Casualty after a market conduct exam of how the insurer handled wind and hail roof claims. This is a state regulatory settlement, not a court judgment and not a class action. The department said the exam found State Farm improperly denied or failed to pay for roof damage and necessary repairs.
The department’s headline says “more than $45 million.” The department’s settlement page breaks the package into three parts that add up to $47.86 million: at least $35 million for homeowners, $10 million for the state’s Strengthen Oklahoma Homes grant program, and $2.86 million in fines and exam costs. The $35 million is a floor, not a per-homeowner payout, and the department has said more can be added if it isn’t enough.
Who can ask for a second look
Eligible claims are wind or hail roof claims with a date of loss between Jan. 1, 2021 and Dec. 31, 2025 that were closed without payment. The department’s release counts partial payments and claims ruled to be under the deductible. A third-party administrator chosen jointly by the department and State Farm will review each claim, and State Farm pays according to the homeowner’s policy if the administrator finds it qualifies.
Like this? Get it in your inbox every week.
What changed in home services this week, and what it means for your shop.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
You’re in. Check your inbox (and drag us to Primary). 🔑
Homeowners must opt in. State Farm has to mail department-approved notices by Dec. 31, and outlets including KOCO and Repairer Driven News have reported a review window of about six months next year. Homeowners with pending lawsuits can be reviewed, according to Oklahoma Voice and KGOU’s reporting on the commissioner’s statements, but must release that litigation to be paid.
What the exam found, and what State Farm says
According to a summary of the exam report by the Property Insurance Coverage Law blog, an independent engineer inspected 58 roofs whose owners gave permission, and examiners found State Farm failed to attempt prompt, fair settlement on at least 22 claims where liability was reasonably clear. That works out to a 12.15% error rate across 181 selected claims, the blog reported. By the blog’s own arithmetic, the rate among the inspected roofs alone was about 38%. The department’s order adopting the report confirms the 58 inspections. Oklahoma Watch reported the exam also found roof claims closed without proper documentation.
State Farm disagrees with the report’s findings and characterizations. Its statement, as reported by KFOR and others, says it has responded to more than 100,000 Oklahoma claims in five years, that a limited review of individual claims should not be mistaken for its overall practices, and that the deal is a negotiated resolution rather than a punitive fine. A sample this size describes the files examined. It does not establish how State Farm handled all of those claims.
The fight isn’t over. Attorney General Gentner Drummond sued State Farm in June in Cleveland County, alleging an internal “Hail Focus Initiative” meant to reduce roof replacement approvals and payments. Those are allegations, and State Farm disputes them. The settlement doesn’t resolve that suit or homeowners’ individual suits. Oklahoma Voice and KGOU reported that Drummond called the deal a last-ditch effort to protect State Farm, not consumers. Oklahoma Watch reported that incoming Commissioner Bob Sullivan, who still called it good news for policyholders who haven’t sued, noted the deal means “there’s a 12-month period where we’re not going to be opening market conduct examinations against State Farm.”
What an Oklahoma roofer can do now
Reported coverage doesn’t say whether the administrator will accept contractor documentation, so nothing here guarantees that your files will count. They are still the one asset you control. Consider pulling the jobs you inspected or bid on between 2021 and 2025 where State Farm denied, underpaid or ruled below the deductible, and check that the dated photos, inspection reports and estimates can be found quickly. A homeowner who opts in may ask you for them.
Expect questions from past customers, and keep your answers factual. Don’t promise outcomes or payment timing. The review timeline isn’t set, and any payment follows each homeowner’s policy.
The release requirement matters for one more situation. If a customer’s lawsuit is tied to a job you’re owed money on, that customer must drop the suit to be paid through this program, so ask where that job stands.
The broader exposure is cash flow. State Farm is Oklahoma’s largest homeowners insurer, with more than 258,000 customers and $785.9 million in 2025 homeowners premiums, according to Oklahoma Watch. A shop with a big share of its work on State Farm claims is tied to one carrier’s handling and timing. That is a concentration risk, and it exists whether or not this settlement changes anything. Checking how much of your backlog and receivables sits with one carrier is a reasonable step.
The settlement covers State Farm in Oklahoma only. No roofer-specific provisions have been reported, so don’t assume it changes how carriers deal with roofers.
Related coverage
Sources
- Oklahoma Insurance Department: Mulready Announces More Than $45 Million in State Farm Settlement
- Oklahoma Insurance Department: State Farm Settlement information page
- Oklahoma Insurance Department: Order Adopting Report of Examination (22-0423 EXM), Nov. 10, 2026
- Oklahoma Attorney General: Drummond files new lawsuit against State Farm (June 24, 2026)
- Oklahoma Watch: State Farm To Pay $45 Million After Oklahoma Insurance Investigation
- Property Insurance Coverage Law blog: State Farm Oklahoma roof claims findings



