- What happened: The Labor Department issued a final rule that makes it easier to classify workers as independent contractors under federal wage-and-hour law, and it takes effect 60 days after Federal Register publication.
- What it means for you: A sub who passes the new federal test can still be an employee under the IRS test, state ABC tests, or state unemployment and workers’ comp rules.
- Do this today: List your regular subs and note who sets their methods and schedule, who owns their equipment, and whether they work for other customers. Then check those answers against your state’s test with a CPA or employment attorney before changing any arrangement.
A federal rule that makes 1099 crews easier to defend is real news. It is still a poor reason to convert or cancel a sub relationship this month. The new test covers one slice of the classification question, and it hasn’t taken effect.
On Nov. 19, the Labor Department’s Wage and Hour Division announced a final rule on who counts as an employee and who counts as an independent contractor under the Fair Labor Standards Act, the federal minimum wage and overtime law. The rule also covers two related laws, the Family and Medical Leave Act and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act. DOL said it takes effect 60 days after it is published in the Federal Register. That publication date hadn’t been confirmed when the rule was announced. Reuters reported the rule will take effect in January, and Fisher Phillips has pointed to roughly mid-January. So the rule is final, not proposed, but not yet in force.
What the new test asks about a sub
- The Labor Department’s Wage and Hour Division announced a final rule on Nov. 19 covering contractor status under the FLSA, FMLA and MSPA.
- It replaces the 2024 rule with a framework similar to the 2021 rule.
- Control over the work and the chance to make or lose money are the two factors that weigh most.
- DOL says it does not change IRS classification or override state or local law.
- The Federal Register publication date, and so the exact effective date (reported as January).
- Whether the rule will be challenged in court.
- How state unemployment agencies and workers’ comp carriers will treat a sub who passes the federal test.
The rule rescinds the Biden-era 2024 rule and replaces it with a framework substantially similar to the one DOL adopted in 2021, according to Roofing Contractor’s account. DOL describes the change as bringing clarity. Reuters reported that it makes it easier for companies in some industries to classify workers as contractors, and that supporters of the 2024 rule say misclassification is rampant and that repealing it strips workers of protections.
Roofing Contractor reports that two factors carry the most weight: how much control the company exercises over the work, and whether the worker can make or lose money through their own initiative or investment. Three others also count: the skill involved, how permanent the relationship is, and whether the work is part of an integrated production process.
Two details matter for a shop that hires crews. Roofing Contractor reports that requiring a sub to follow safety standards, meet deadlines or meet quality requirements does not automatically make that sub an employee. It also reports that the actual working arrangement carries more weight than the wording of the sub agreement. SHRM’s summary of the rule, drawing on DOL’s Fact Sheet 13, adds that holding a state or local license and the company’s contributing to portable benefits don’t help decide status either.
The proposal that preceded the rule included roofing examples. In one, a commercial roofer hired for skills he already had, with no training from the company and who advertises those skills to the company and others, points toward contractor status on the skill factor. A crew worker with no roofing skills when hired does not. Fisher Phillips says the examples carried into the final rule.
Like this? Get it in your inbox every Saturday.
What changed in home services this week, and what it means for your shop.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
You’re in. Check your inbox (and drag us to Primary). 🔑
What the rule leaves open
DOL says the rule does not change how workers are classified under other federal laws, including the Internal Revenue Code, and does not override state or local laws. Littler, the employment law firm, makes the practical point: a worker who qualifies as a contractor under the new federal rule may still be an employee under state law.
That is where owners get hurt. A sub can pass the federal wage-and-hour test and still fail the IRS’s separate test, which, according to Anomaly CPA’s explainer of IRS guidance, is not decided by a 1099 form or a contract label. Some states apply stricter “ABC” tests; secondary compliance explainers describe these as presuming a worker is an employee unless the company proves the worker is free from its control, does work outside its usual business, and runs an independent business. State unemployment insurance and workers’ comp rules are separate again, and nothing in the DOL announcement addresses them. Whether those agencies, or a workers’ comp carrier, will treat a sub who passes the federal test as a contractor is a question for an attorney or CPA, not something the rule answers.
A crew that works only for your company, on your schedule, with your tools and your instructions looks risky under any of these tests, since control and the lack of any chance to profit or lose are the factors DOL says matter most.
The federal standard has also flipped repeatedly: a 2021 rule, a 2024 replacement, and now a return to something like 2021, according to DOL’s rulemaking page and Congressional Research Service summaries. Business groups backed this change and worker advocates oppose it. No court challenge had been reported as of Nov. 20, but a future reversal is possible. Restructuring a labor model around one version of one federal test carries that risk.
Before changing any sub arrangement
The useful exercise is to pull each regular sub and sort the facts, rather than react to the headline.
- List each regular sub and note who sets their methods and schedule.
- Note whether the sub owns the equipment, hires helpers, buys materials and carries their own insurance.
- Note whether they work for other customers and market themselves to them, and whether the skill was there before they started with you.
- Check those answers against your state’s test and your workers’ comp and unemployment rules with a CPA or employment attorney.
- Make sure your written agreements match the day-to-day arrangement. They only help when they do.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division news release (Nov. 19, 2026)
- U.S. Department of Labor, Fact Sheet #13: Employee or Independent Contractor Classification Under the FLSA
- Regulations.gov, DOL proposed rule WHD-2026-0001 (Feb. 2026)
- Roofing Contractor, “DOL Rule Changes How Roofers Classify Subcontractors” (Nov. 20, 2026)
- Littler, “DOL Releases Final Rule Regarding Independent Contractor Status” (Nov. 19, 2026)
- Reuters via Yahoo Finance (Nov. 19, 2026)
Disclosure: Digital Insider’s founder, Joshua T. Osborne, owns home service companies and Mr & Mrs Leads, a lead generation company. Some links on Digital Insider may earn us a commission. See our Disclosure Policy.



