The Business Behind Home Services.

Topics  ·  About  ·  Submit a Tip  ·  Advertise

FirstService now expects to owe sellers $15.8M less in earnouts

A public buyer’s earnout IOUs to sellers fell about two-thirds in nine months, and only part of that was cash paid out; what the filing shows, and what it doesn’t.

·

· 6 min read

A desk with printed financial statements, a calculator, and a laptop showing a spreadsheet, representing a review of acquisition earnout liabilities in a company filing.

Between Jan. 1 and Sept. 30, 2026, the amount FirstService owed to sellers of businesses it had already bought fell from $47.0 million to $15.3 million, according to its third-quarter financial statements. That is a drop of about two-thirds (Digital Insider calculation: $46,952K minus $15,324K is $31,628K, or 67%). Two reductions drove it: $22.3 million was money that actually reached sellers, and another $15.8 million was the company deciding it would probably owe less. New earnouts of $6.6 million from this year’s deals partly offset those two reductions.

If a buyer ever offers you part of your price as an earnout, that second number is the one to study. It shows how the buyer’s books treat your promise: as an estimate that gets re-scored every quarter.

Where the $31.6 million went

An earnout is the part of the purchase price a seller collects later, if the business hits earnings targets after closing. FirstService’s filings say its earnouts pay out if an acquired business reaches specified earnings levels over a one- to two-year period. The payout follows a formula with a contractual maximum, which is reduced for any shortfall, “potentially to nil,” according to the company’s 2025 annual statements. The buyer re-estimates the amount every quarter. The 2025 statements say it uses a discounted cash-flow model with discount rates of 8% to 10%.

Cash paid to sellers was bigger than the estimate cut, and both shrank the liability
Nine months to Sept. 30, 2026 · $M
Paid to sellers in cash22.3Cut to expected payouts15.8
Source: FirstService Q3 2026 cash-flow statement. Both bars are reductions to FirstService's earnout liability. They don't add up to the full drop, because $6.6 million of new earnouts on 2026 deals was added over the same period.
Show the data
Value ($M)
Paid to sellers in cash22.3
Cut to expected payouts15.8

The nine-month roll-forward, in thousands of dollars, from the balance sheet and cash-flow statement:

Like this? Get it in your inbox every week.

What changed in home services this week, and what it means for your shop.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

ItemNine months to Sept. 30, 2026 ($K)
Earnout liability, Jan. 1 (reported)46,952
New earnouts on 2026 deals (reported)+6,563
Fair value adjustments (reported)-15,772
Paid to sellers in cash (reported)-22,310
Sum of the above (Digital Insider calculation)15,433
Earnout liability, Sept. 30 (reported)15,324

The $109K gap between the sum and the reported balance is small, and the statements don’t explain it. The figures otherwise line up.

Two things stand out. Sellers got paid: $22.3 million of earnouts went out in cash, against $7.8 million in the same nine months of 2025, or nearly three times as much (Digital Insider calculation: $22,310K divided by $7,825K is 2.85). And the company cut $15.8 million from what it expected to pay, where a year earlier the adjustment went the other way, adding $7.6 million to the liability.

A downward adjustment is a gain on the buyer’s books, not a loss. The filings do not tie the $15.8 million to any particular deal, and the company says the balance mostly covers deals from the past two years, so it should not be read as a write-down of the six Brands shops FirstService bought this year (it also bought a Palm Beach property manager).

The cut came early in the year

Balance sheets from the quarterly filings show the liability at $47.0 million at Dec. 31, $33.7 million at June 30 and $15.3 million at Sept. 30. The cash-flow statement shows a $1.4 million upward adjustment in the third quarter. Subtracting it from the nine-month figure, the first-half reversal was about $17.2 million (Digital Insider calculation: $15,772K plus $1,432K). The third-quarter drop came from payments, not from further cuts. By Digital Insider’s calculation, the liability fell $18,373K in the quarter ($33,697K to $15,324K); adding back the $1,432K upward adjustment gives about $19.8 million of payments, since the nine-month new-earnout figure of $6,563K is the same as at the half-year. FirstService’s first-half report called the year-to-date result a reversal of fair value adjustments on earnouts in its Brands segment. It gave no reason.

One detail suggests how quickly expectations can move. At Dec. 31, 2025, the company’s disclosed range of possible payouts ran from $40.8 million to $48.0 million, and it carried $47.0 million, about 98% of the top of that range (Digital Insider calculation: $46,952K divided by $48,048K). By June 30 the range was $29.8 million to $39.7 million against $33.7 million booked, about 85% of the maximum (Digital Insider calculation: $33,697K divided by $39,675K). The ranges shrink as earnouts are paid or expire, so the dollar figures aren’t directly comparable. The ratio is. At year-end the company was carrying earnouts close to a full payout, and six months later it wasn’t.

The swing runs both ways. FirstService’s 2024 annual MD&A says it reversed $20.0 million of earnout liabilities in 2024 and had booked a $16.4 million increase in 2023 for outperformance on earlier deals. A buyer’s liability rises when acquired shops beat their targets and falls when they are expected to miss.

What the filing leaves out

The statements don’t say which deals were revalued, whether any of this year’s seven acquisitions were among them, or what changed. A cut could reflect missed targets, changed assumptions or timing. Anything beyond that would be speculation, and a lower liability does not show that any seller was shortchanged.

Context from the company is limited. On the third-quarter call, as summarized by MarketBeat, the CFO said roofing revenue fell 4% reported and by a high-single-digit percentage organically, on lower volume and gross-margin pressure mostly in Florida. The company expected the competitive pressure to last at least through the fourth quarter. The same summary says Century Fire, the fire protection business, grew revenue more than 10%. The filing does not say whether the roofer FirstService bought in Kansas City, or any other shop, is affected by the cut. Roofing is one weak segment inside one company, not a verdict on roofing earnouts generally.

The earnings picture is mixed, and the earnout line plays a part. FirstService’s operating earnings fell to $107.4 million in the third quarter from $115.6 million. The company’s own release says Q3 2025 was helped by earnout reversals, and the cash-flow statement shows a $5.8 million reversal in that quarter against a $1.4 million expense this year. In the release, adjusted EBITDA rose 3% to $169.7 million, and Brands adjusted EBITDA was $101.8 million against $102.1 million. Brands margin on that measure slipped to 11.3% from 12.1%.

Reading an earnout offer with this in hand

At this buyer, earnouts are a minority of the initial consideration. Here that means contingent consideration booked at its estimated fair value on the acquisition date, which is discounted and adjusted for risk. It is not the maximum payout, and it is not necessarily the share of the headline price on a letter of intent. In nine months FirstService reported $73.2 million of cash paid for acquisitions, net of cash acquired, and $6.6 million of new contingent consideration. By Digital Insider’s calculation that is about 8% of the combined total ($6,563K divided by $79,754K), compared with about 6% in the same period of 2025 ($5,683K divided by $102,068K). On the first-half deals alone, it was about 12% (Digital Insider calculation from the Q2 statements: $6,563K of contingent consideration divided by $54,986K, which is $48,423K of cash paid net of cash acquired plus the $6,563K). The figures cover seven acquisitions each year, including a property manager, and the release gives no per-shop price. Cash spent fell 24% year over year (Digital Insider calculation: $73,191K in 2026 versus $96,385K in 2025), but with the deal mix unknown, that should not be read as lower prices. Your offer may carry a much bigger share on the back end.

A few practical points follow from how the filing describes the mechanics:

  • Treat the earnout as less than face value when you compare offers. The buyer itself discounts it at 8% to 10% and adjusts it for expected performance. A dollar of cash at close and a dollar of earnout are not the same dollar.
  • Pin down the earnings measure. With a formula that cuts payment for any shortfall, potentially to nil, everything depends on how “earnings” is defined: which costs are charged to your unit, who controls marketing and hiring spend, and what happens if the buyer changes how the business operates.
  • Ask for the numbers as they accrue. The buyer re-scores your earnout every quarter. You can ask to see the same tracking, rather than learning the result at the end of the one- to two-year window.
  • Weigh your segment. If the business you’re selling is in a market under volume or margin pressure, a target set at closing can be harder to hit a year later. That is a reason to push for a lower earnout share, or a lower bar, not proof that any buyer behaves badly.

The same filing shows that earnouts do get paid, and a lot more cash went out this year than last. A seller who hits the targets collects. The risk is the gap between the price on the letter of intent and the earnings the contract lets you count.

Sources

Written by

Meet the Digital Insider team →

The business behind home services, in your inbox

Your weekly read on the marketing, AI, private equity and tech changing how homeowners hire and how shops get bought.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Latest

More from Digital Insider

Run a home service business? Get the Insider.

One email a week on the marketing, AI, private equity and tech reshaping the trades. Written by an owner, for owners.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.