The price per lead is the number in every vendor pitch. The contract decides how many of those leads you can use, how many you get credit for when they fall apart, and what it costs to leave. Owners who compare vendors on price per lead alone are comparing the wrong number.
A disclosure first: Digital Insider’s founder owns home service companies and sells lead generation. The six questions below apply to any lead seller, including one connected to this publication. They are built from the published terms of three large platforms. Before you sign with any private vendor, get its contract and check it against these six questions.
What the big platforms actually write down
Google’s Local Services Ads help pages say the company now handles lead credits automatically instead of through manual disputes. Google says it assesses a lead when it first comes in and does not charge for those it judges invalid or low quality. Charged leads are reassessed over time and may be credited automatically, usually to the account balance within 30 days. The original charge still shows on the invoice. Google’s page also says it no longer supports credits for leads where the job type or the geography isn’t one you serve. That puts the burden on how you set up your account.
Angi’s help center sets a different set of conditions. A lead must be under 45 days old and the account in good standing with no overdue balance. Angi says it reviews requests within five business days. It lists “homeowner hired another pro before you reached them” as ineligible for credit, on the grounds that this risk is already priced into the lead. Pine, Sourci and Norzer, which summarize Angi’s policy, add further conditions: a call attempt within 24 hours, credits that apply to future leads and expire after six months, and no credits for annual-subscription accounts. One of the summaries says an older HomeAdvisor page gives a 30-day window. So it’s worth asking which document governs your account.
Like this? Get it in your inbox every week.
What changed in home services this week, and what it means for your shop.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
You’re in. Check your inbox (and drag us to Primary). 🔑
Thumbtack’s automatic refund, which it calls the Fair Shot Refund, applies when the customer doesn’t reply to any pro within 72 hours. Thumbtack says the pro must have communicated through its platform. Sharing a personal phone number or email before the customer replies makes the lead ineligible.
The common thread is that a “bad lead” is defined narrowly, often by what the owner did. A lead can be real, from a real homeowner, and still be one you can’t book. Most of these remedies are also account credits, not cash.
What the FTC’s HomeAdvisor order says about lead marketing
Marketing claims are a separate matter from contract terms, and the FTC has already looked at them. In April 2023 the agency finalized an order against HomeAdvisor, an Angi affiliate, requiring up to $7.2 million in redress. The FTC alleged that since at least mid-2014 the company made false or unsubstantiated claims about lead quality, where its leads came from and how often they turned into jobs.
The order bars claims such as leads being “ready to hire” that the company can’t support. For a buyer, the takeaway is practical: the sales deck and the signed terms are different documents, and only one of them binds the vendor.
The six clauses to check
- Exclusivity. Ask whether each lead goes to you alone, in writing, and what the vendor means by that. Trade guides describe exclusivity as the vendor’s promise not to resell the lead. It does not stop the homeowner from calling other companies. A write-up from getmodernwebsites.com reports that Angi’s help center allows a request to go to as many as five pros. Google’s lead-credit pages say nothing either way about exclusivity. Marketplaces don’t all work the same way, so the definition has to be in your contract.
- What counts as a bad lead. Get the list of credit reasons. Check whether wrong job type, out-of-area, duplicates, disconnected numbers and spam are on it. Also check whether “the homeowner hired someone else” is excluded, as it is at Angi.
- Refund or credit window. Ask how many days you have, whether the vendor reviews leads automatically or you must file a request, and which document sets the rule. Get the controlling terms with a date on them.
- Call recording. Ask whether you get recordings of the calls you’re billed for, because you can’t dispute what you can’t hear. Google’s help page says recordings and credits aren’t available for tax specialists or US health care verticals, which shows that availability varies. Ask your attorney about a vendor’s recording practices.
- Minimum spend. Ask whether there is a monthly commitment, a prepaid balance or a ramp-up period, and what happens to leads you can’t work in a slow month.
- Cancellation. Ask for the notice period, any early termination fee, renewal terms and price increases, which document controls if the standard terms and your signed order differ, and whether unused credit is paid out or lost when you leave. If remedies come as account credit, credit on a closed account may be worth nothing.
Why cancellation deserves the most attention
Here is a hypothetical, not a description of any particular vendor. Say you sign a 12-month lead agreement at $2,000 a month. Three months in, your cost per booked job is double what you expected, and you decide to leave. If the contract requires you to pay out the remaining nine months, or charges an early termination fee, you owe up to $18,000 on top of the $6,000 you’ve already spent. What looked like a $2,000-a-month test is a $24,000 commitment.
That’s why the cancellation language is worth reading before the price. A contract you can exit in 30 days makes a bad month cheap. One you can’t exit makes it expensive.
Compare cost per booked job
The number worth tracking is spend after credits divided by jobs booked. Here is another hypothetical. A shop buys 100 leads at $50 each, $5,000 in total, and gets $400 credited back. If it books 12 jobs, each costs about $383. If it books 24, each costs about $192. The vendor that charges more per lead but sends exclusive, bookable calls can come out cheaper, and the credit terms are the only thing in the contract that moves the first number.
Google’s October 1 billing change
Search Engine Land, reporting on Google’s notice to advertisers, said that starting October 1, 2026, Google charges for some missed calls. Under the notice, a call during business hours counts as a billed lead if the caller stays on the line more than 20 seconds, with some exceptions. Follow-up calls that meet the valid-lead criteria can also be charged. Google said it was adding safeguards against spam and robot calls but has not fully explained how they work.
Google’s October 1 billing change means phone coverage can now affect what a Local Services Ads advertiser is charged. Check three things: which numbers and hours your ads route to, whether after-hours calls go to voicemail or a live answer, and whether your job types and service area in the account are accurate. Google no longer credits leads outside them.
Related coverage
Sources
- Google Local Services Help: About Automated Local Services Ads lead credits
- Google Local Services Help: How leads work
- Angi help center: How to Request a Lead Credit
- Thumbtack Help Center: Fair Shot Refund policy
- FTC: FTC approves final order against HomeAdvisor (April 2023)
- Search Engine Land: Google Local Services Ads will charge for some missed calls starting Oct. 1
More on this topic: Google & Local Search coverage



