The Business Behind Home Services.

Topics  ·  About  ·  Submit a Tip  ·  Advertise

Ask the Robots Who to Hire. Is Your Shop in the Answer?

Homeowners may soon ask an AI for three plumbers instead of scrolling ten listings, and a simple test will show whether your shop gets named.

By Josh Osborne

·

· 9 min read

A homeowner sits at a kitchen counter looking at her phone while a plumber's service van waits in the driveway outside.

Picture a call coming into your office. Your CSR picks up, and the homeowner says, “I found you through ChatGPT.” She asks what they searched. “I asked who I should call for a water heater replacement, and it recommended you.”

That’s the call I’d want to study, because the interesting part isn’t that your name came up. It’s why that homeowner trusted the answer enough to pick up the phone.

Maybe the answer quoted your reviews. Maybe it described your services or linked your website. Maybe it just put your name in front of her at the right moment. Without the actual answer, nobody knows.

Think about how different that is from traditional search. She might never have looked through the map pack, compared five websites or clicked a paid ad. She asked a question, got a recommendation and dialed.

Like this? Get it in your inbox every week.

What changed in home services this week, and what it means for your shop.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Full disclosure: I own home service companies, and I sell lead generation. That means I have a business interest in contractors paying attention to how customers find them online, and in agencies not eating the budget first. Weigh everything below with that in mind. I’ve spent years studying how home service companies show up in Google search, Google Maps and organic results, and I think this deserves your attention anyway.

Where the pressure drops

When we pressure-test a plumbing system, we cap the line, pump it up and watch the gauge. A leak shows up as a drop in pressure. You don’t have to guess where the problem is. You watch where the pressure goes.

That’s how I’d treat AI answers. Run the test, watch the gauge and see where your shop disappears.

Here’s what I’d keep in mind going in. Ranking number one in Google Maps doesn’t automatically mean ChatGPT will recommend you. If ChatGPT names your competitor today, that doesn’t mean it names them tomorrow. These systems don’t necessarily use the same information, and the answer can change depending on exactly what the homeowner asks.

I’m not claiming homeowners have already moved to AI in big numbers. My point is narrower. If they start asking an AI to recommend three companies instead of scrolling through ten listings, being absent from that answer could become a serious visibility problem.

The test: three questions, three tools

  1. The emergency question. “Who’s the best plumber in [your city] for an emergency water heater replacement?”
  2. The reputation question. “Which local plumbing company has the strongest reputation for water heater installations?”
  3. The budget question. “Who would you recommend for an affordable, reliable plumber near me?”

Swap in your own trade and your best-selling job. Run all three in ChatGPT, in Google’s AI features and in one other AI search tool. That’s nine answers. Write down every company named.

Now the part most owners will skip. Don’t just record whether you were mentioned. Read what the answer says about the businesses it does recommend. Is it talking about reviews? Emergency availability? Years in business? Specific services? Pricing?

Those are clues about what information showed up in the answer. Clues aren’t proof of what caused the result, and they aren’t proof of how any system ranks businesses.

On my own plumbing company, I’d ask the emergency question for our main city and see whether we appear. If it does, I’d read what the answer says about us: service areas, reviews, emergency availability, specific services. Then I’d run the same question for Denver, Aurora and the other markets we serve. I don’t just want to know whether AI recognizes my company. I want to know whether it connects us to the services and places where we actually want more customers.

I’d record the competitors too. If the same three companies keep showing up, I’d study what’s publicly available about them. Not because I think I’ve found a secret algorithm. When you’re trying to understand a new channel, you start by studying what’s actually happening.

The invisible assist

Here’s why I’d also change how you track customers. I own a plumbing company, so I’ll use it as the example. Say a homeowner asks ChatGPT for the best plumber in Arvada, and it names three companies. She sees Spartan Plumbing, looks us up on Google, reads our reviews and calls through our Google Business Profile.

What does the tracking say? Google Business Profile. What got us considered in the first place? Potentially ChatGPT. I call that the invisible assist: the AI makes the first touch, and Google gets the credit in your report.

ServiceTitan, Housecall Pro, CallRail and plenty of other tools can tell you where a call can be attributed. They don’t necessarily tell you everything that influenced the decision. Those are two very different things, and unless you ask the customer, you may never see the gap.

We’ve spent years getting extremely detailed about where our leads come from. I think we’re entering a period where the way somebody discovers a company and the place they actually call from could be completely different. Tracking which number somebody dialed doesn’t tell you how they found you.

My read

I’d have CSRs ask two questions on every new-customer call:

  • “Where did you find our phone number today?”
  • “Was there anything that made you choose us over the other companies?”

The first identifies the call source. The second identifies what moved the customer.

I’d also create a separate option in the CRM for AI-assisted discovery: ChatGPT, Google AI and other assistants. I don’t expect it to be 30% of our business tomorrow. I want to start collecting the data before everybody decides they need it.

Now the part some owners won’t like. The homeowner doesn’t know how good you are. They know what they can find about you. You might have been the best electrician in your city for 20 years, stood behind every job and have hundreds of happy customers. But if you have 17 Google reviews, a website nobody’s touched since 2018 and barely any information about your services online, how is someone researching you supposed to know? How is an AI system supposed to describe what you do with any confidence?

I don’t think the company with the most reviews should automatically win. Review volume doesn’t prove quality, and 2,000 reviews don’t make a shop better than one with 200. But contractors don’t get to ignore their online reputation for ten years and then complain when competitors are easier to discover.

I’d push back on the AI companies too. If recommendations lean too hard on whoever has the biggest online footprint, we risk building a system where the best marketer beats the best contractor. I’ve been in digital marketing long enough to know those aren’t always the same person.

The best contractor in town shouldn’t have to become the best marketer in town to get a fair shot. But if nobody can find evidence of your work, you’re making it a hell of a lot harder for customers to choose you.

I also think contractors are going to get this wrong by treating AI search like magic that requires throwing out everything they know about local SEO. If your Google Business Profile has bad information, your website barely explains what you do and you have almost no evidence of real work, why are you worried about some secret ChatGPT strategy? Fix those first. Then start testing how AI describes you.

None of that guarantees ChatGPT will recommend you, and nobody can honestly promise it will. But it improves the quality of information available about your business, and that’s worth something on any search platform.

The other side

The strongest counterargument is that this test is noisy. Answers change with the wording of the question and can change from one day to the next. Nine answers in one afternoon is a snapshot, not a trend. Meanwhile the map pack and your Google reviews still drive the calls you can measure today, and chasing a new channel before you’ve fixed your basics is how owners waste money.

That’s a fair point, and I’m not telling you to pull budget from anything. I’m not interested in taking money away from channels that already produce profitable customers. I’m telling you to take a free reading and start asking customers a better question.

Who gains, who loses

The shops that gain are the ones with accurate profiles, real reviews, clear service pages and photos of actual work. The shops that lose are the good ones with thin footprints, because the work is real but nobody can find proof of it.

My prediction is that marketing agencies selling fear will make a killing on this before most contractors understand it. They’ll take everything they learned selling SEO and repackage it as AI optimization. Suddenly every contractor hears that they’re invisible on ChatGPT and need another $2,500-a-month service to fix it.

I can already imagine the pitch: “We’ll get you ranked number one in ChatGPT.” Really? Show me how you’re guaranteeing that. Show me where ChatGPT publishes a stable local ranking algorithm. Show me the data proving that what you’re charging me produces more booked jobs and collected revenue. Being mentioned by an AI tool and generating profitable customers are two completely different things.

I’m not saying there’s no opportunity in helping businesses get discovered through AI. I think there’s a tremendous one. But improving a company’s digital presence is different from pretending you control what an AI recommends. The contractors most likely to get burned are the ones who already feel like they’re falling behind. They’ll spend because they’re afraid of missing out, not because anyone proved the math.

Contractor action checklist

  • This week: run the three questions in three tools for every market you serve, and log every company named along with what each answer says about it.
  • Read for clues: note whether reviews, emergency availability, years in business, specific services or pricing show up in each description.
  • Add an “AI-assisted discovery” source in your CRM (ChatGPT, Google AI, other assistants), and train CSRs on the two questions. Have them put the answer to the second one in the ticket notes.
  • Fix the basics: ask happy customers for honest reviews, correct your business information everywhere it appears, post real examples of your techs’ work and build service pages that say what you do and where you do it.
  • Test any agency pitch: if someone promises to rank you number one in ChatGPT, ask them to put the guarantee in writing and explain exactly how they’ll measure it. Watch how quickly the sales conversation changes.
  • Put a reminder on the calendar to run the same nine questions again next month and compare. If the answers moved, you’ve learned how unstable they are.

What would change my mind

Three things would make me reconsider how much attention we give this.

  1. We ask every new customer whether AI influenced their decision, and six months later practically nobody says yes. I’m not going to pretend it’s generating business just because the technology is exciting.
  2. We repeatedly test the same services and markets and the answers are so inconsistent we can’t find a useful pattern. I’d be very cautious about investing heavily in trying to influence results like that.
  3. We see more AI mentions but none of that visibility turns into calls, booked appointments or collected revenue.

Visibility doesn’t pay payroll. Booked jobs and collected revenue do. I wouldn’t stop watching AI entirely, because the way customers search for businesses is changing. But I’m not interested in winning an AI popularity contest. I’m interested in generating profitable customers.

Run the test this week and write down what you see. Then have your CSRs ask one more question on every call, and don’t spend another dollar convincing an AI you’re the best in town until a homeowner can actually find the evidence.

Josh Osborne

Josh Osborne owns six home service companies and writes Digital Insider from the owner’s chair: what’s changing in marketing, AI and private equity, and what it means for the people running the trucks.

The business behind home services, in your inbox

Your weekly read on the marketing, AI, private equity and tech changing how homeowners hire and how shops get bought.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Latest

More from Digital Insider

Run a home service business? Get the Insider.

One email a week on the marketing, AI, private equity and tech reshaping the trades. Written by an owner, for owners.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.